Pan toasting bread with butter can result in a better outcome compared to putting buttered bread directly in the toaster oven due to several reasons:
Even Distribution of Butter: When you pan toast bread with butter, you have more control over the amount and distribution of butter on the bread's surface. You can spread the butter evenly or melt it across the pan, ensuring that each part of the bread is coated. In contrast, putting buttered bread in a toaster oven might lead to uneven distribution, with some parts getting more butter than others.
Crispiness and Texture: Pan toasting allows the bread to come into direct contact with the hot surface of the pan. This direct contact helps in achieving a more consistent and crispy texture on both sides of the bread. On the other hand, when you put buttered bread in a toaster oven, the heat might not reach the bread's surface as evenly, leading to uneven toasting and potential sogginess.
Control Over Browning: Pan toasting gives you better control over the level of browning you desire. You can adjust the heat and cooking time according to your preference. In a toaster oven, the browning might be less predictable, especially if you have a limited range of settings.
Butter Infusion: Pan toasting allows the butter to infuse into the bread as it toasts. The bread absorbs the melted butter, adding a rich flavor and enhancing the overall taste. In a toaster oven, the butter remains on the bread's surface, and the flavor infusion might not be as pronounced.
No Risk of Dripping: When you pan toast bread with butter, any excess butter usually stays in the pan. In a toaster oven, there's a possibility that some butter might drip off the bread and onto the oven's heating elements, potentially causing smoke or unpleasant smells.
It's important to note that personal preferences vary, and some people may still prefer the convenience of using a toaster oven to make toast with butter. However, pan toasting does offer more control over the toasting process and can lead to a more satisfying and flavorful result for those who enjoy a crispy, buttery slice of toast.