Yes, it is generally acceptable to ask your neighbors to share the cost of replacing a shared fence, especially if they would also benefit from the new fence. It is common practice for neighbors to split the cost of a fence that serves as a boundary between their properties.
When approaching your neighbors about sharing the cost, it's important to be courteous and open to their input. Here are some suggestions on how to handle the conversation:
Schedule a meeting: Reach out to your neighbors and propose a meeting to discuss the fence replacement. This allows everyone to be present and share their thoughts.
Explain the situation: Clearly explain the condition of the existing fence and the need for its replacement. Emphasize the benefits of having a new fence, such as increased privacy, improved aesthetics, and potential property value enhancement.
Discuss cost-sharing options: Present your neighbors with a proposal for sharing the cost. You can suggest dividing the total expense equally among all parties or calculating the share based on the linear footage each property contributes to the fence line. Be open to negotiation and find a solution that works for everyone.
Obtain multiple quotes: Get quotes from different contractors for the fence replacement and share these estimates with your neighbors. This will provide transparency and help in determining a fair cost-sharing arrangement.
Put it in writing: If your neighbors agree to contribute to the cost, it is advisable to document the agreement in writing. This can include the details of the cost-sharing arrangement, the type of fence to be installed, and any other agreed-upon terms.
Remember, approaching the discussion with a cooperative and respectful attitude increases the likelihood of reaching a mutually beneficial agreement.